Allegany County, MD Real Estate | Allegany County, MD Homes between $500,000 and $600,000 for Sale

Sprawling 4-bedroom, 3-bath custom home set on nearly 4 private acres in LaVale! Boasting over 3,500 sq ft of finished above-grade space, this home combines thoughtful design with impressive outdoor features. Enjoy main-level living complete with a primary suite, main-floor laundry, 3 entertainment spaces (living/family/sunroom) formal dining room and gorgeous kitchen! The upper level provides three bedrooms, a full bath, and a versatile bonus room for that home office, gym or playroom. Outdoor living shines with a wraparound deck, patio, custom stone hardscaping, exterior lighting, and a hot tub to enjoy those quiet evenings. Additional highlights include a 3-car attached garage, tankless water heater, natural gas heat, solar panel system and a huge unfinished walk-out basement if you need more space. A rare find offering space, privacy, and public utilities!

11900 Cash Valley Rd Nw, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Charis Realty Group. Contact: 2408015011

$575,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Mountain Chalet on Nearly 32 Acres with Panoramic Views! Mountain Chalet on Nearly 32 Acres with Panoramic Views! Welcome to your own private mountain retreat! Perched high on Martins Mountain, this beautiful 3-bedroom, 3-bath chalet offers nearly 32 acres of breathtaking natural beauty, privacy, and panoramic views. This home features an inviting open concept, a full walk-out basement, and an attached garage, providing plenty of room for family, guests, hobbies, and storage. Step outside onto your wonderful deck and take in the spectacular mountain vistas while enjoying your morning coffee, entertaining friends, or simply relaxing in your peaceful surroundings. The property is truly a nature lover's dream. The acreage extends down to Frog Hollow Lane and includes fields, pastures, fenced areas, and 4-wheeler trails, offering endless opportunities for hiking, recreation, gardening, animals, hunting, or simply exploring your own piece of the mountain. Property Highlights: Nearly 32 acres on Martins Mountain 3 bedrooms/3 Full Baths Attached garage Expansive deck overlooking the mountains Greenhouse Barn, chicken house, additional shed 4 tree-stands for hunting remain on property Rheem Furnace with air conditions, approx. 8 years old Seamless gutters Metal roof with 40-year guarantee Fields, pastures, and fenced areas Mountain Living Made Easy This property is serviced by the Martins Mountain Water Company, providing access to exceptional spring water. The private road association, which is $300.00/year includes snow removal and road maintenance. Whether you envision a peaceful mountain getaway, a full-time residence, a recreational property, or a place to enjoy gardening and raising animals, this extraordinary property offers the space, views, and privacy to make those dreams a reality. Come experience the serenity of Martins Mountain and discover everything this remarkable property has to offer.

14700 Martins Mountain Ln, Oldtown

Listing courtesy of Railey Realty, Inc.. Contact:

$500,000

24 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths

8 Unit investment Apartment Building in the heart of Frostburg University. The building consists of 8 units of 3 Bedrooms and 1 Bathrooms split over 2 floors. 5 Units are currently rented and 3 are vacant. The total rent collected currently varies but $40,000 was collected last school year. The owner has 51 other units in Frostburg walking distance to the University. All properties have been maintained by an in house property manager. A portfolio sale of all 59 units can also be an option. 12 units are currently vacant. Gross income in 2025 $448,000. Seller financing is available for a portfolio buyer.

109 S Broadway St, Frostburg

Listing courtesy of Terrapin Realtors, Inc. Contact: (301) 355-5000

$510,000

Welcome to 411 Washington Street! This circa late-1800s home is ideally located in the heart of the Washington Street Historic District and offers sweeping views of the area's iconic historic homes. This versatile multi-family property is perfect for investors, owner-occupants looking to generate rental income to offset expenses, or anyone dreaming of restoring it to its original grandeur as one magnificent single-family residence. The main-level apartment features a formal living room, formal dining room, two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a spacious kitchen open to the family room, and access to the basement. The second-floor apartment is an oversized two-bedroom, two-bathroom unit that could easily be converted back into two separate one-bedroom apartments, while the third-floor unit offers one bedroom and one bathroom. The basement provides excellent potential to be finished for additional living or storage space and includes two one-car garages. Situated on a large lot, the property offers ample space for a yard, off-street parking, and more. Each unit has separate electric meters and is heated by electric baseboard heat, making this a unique opportunity with endless possibilities in one of the area's most desirable historic neighborhoods. Minutes from Downtown Cumberland and I-68. Call today for more information!

411 Washington St, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Mountainside Home Realty. Contact: 3017220190

$525,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Prepare to be impressed by this spectacular 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath custom home where timeless elegance meets exceptional comfort. From the moment you step into the grand foyer, you'll appreciate the impressive scale, refined finishes, and thoughtfully designed floor plan that make this home truly unforgettable. Designed for both everyday living and grand entertaining, the main level features an expansive family room, an elegant formal living room, and an oversized dining room perfect for hosting family and friends. At the heart of the home, the stunning chef's kitchen is both beautiful and functional, opening seamlessly to the sun-filled breakfast room and inviting sunroom—perfect for morning coffee or quiet evenings overlooking the backyard. Everyday living is effortless with a main-level laundry room, an oversized mudroom, and convenient access to the attached two-car garage. Upstairs, escape to the luxurious primary suite, a private retreat offering generous space to unwind, while three additional bedrooms and a dedicated upper-level study provide flexibility for today's lifestyle. The finished walk-out lower level is an entertainer's dream, offering abundant recreation space along with a charming wine cellar that's sure to impress guests. Outside, your own private resort awaits. Relax on expansive decks, entertain on the patio, or spend summer days enjoying the sparkling in-ground pool, all surrounded by a beautifully fenced yard offering privacy and room to roam. From grand entertaining to everyday living, every space has been designed with comfort, style, and functionality in mind. This extraordinary property delivers the space, amenities, and lifestyle you've been searching for—a place you'll be proud to call home.

1022 Cherrywood Ave, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Premier. Contact: (301) 777-3380

$598,777

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

UPDATE: Seller offering a $3,000 credit at closing with acceptable offer! Mountain living meets modern comfort on this beautifully remodeled property offering 44± acres of privacy, recreation, and breathtaking scenery on the outskirts of Cumberland — just minutes from downtown and UPMC hospital! Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, hunting retreat, or hobby farm, this Appalachian hideaway delivers the space and features to make it happen. This home offers 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, with tasteful updates throughout. New luxury vinyl plank flooring and carpet create a fresh, inviting feel, while the open-concept main level is perfectly suited for entertaining. The spacious primary suite features a walk-in closet and convenient laundry area, creating a comfortable private retreat. The attached garage is equipped with mini-split heating and cooling systems along with a half bath, making it an excellent workshop, hobby space, or year-round storage area. Outside, the possibilities are endless! Explore your own 44 acres of wooded mountain land, ideal for hunting, hiking, ATV riding, and enjoying nature right from your doorstep. Additional features include a chicken coop, duck pen, and a versatile outbuilding that was formerly used as a walk-in cooler. Major improvements include a new roof and gutter system installed in 2024, all-new HVAC, and a durable LP® SmartSide® exterior for lasting curb appeal and peace of mind. If you’ve been searching for a move-in-ready home with acreage, modern updates, and room to embrace the outdoors, this Appalachian gem is one you won’t want to miss. Schedule your showing today and experience all that this remarkable property has to offer!

11900 Messick Rd Se, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of The KW Collective. Contact: 3017222020

$599,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Tucked away at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac in one of Cumberland’s premier neighborhoods, 10002 Carrington Court offers luxury, comfort, and breathtaking mountain views in every direction — all with convenient access to I-68 and no city taxes! Ideally located just minutes from UPMC Western Maryland, Allegany College of Maryland, downtown Cumberland, shopping, restaurants, and more. This immaculate all-brick ranch home showcases quality craftsmanship and thoughtful upgrades throughout. Step inside through the elegant cut-glass entry door with sidelights into a welcoming foyer that opens to a spacious main level featuring vaulted ceilings, custom built-ins, rich oak trim, and solid oak doors. The inviting living room is anchored by a stunning double-sided propane fireplace shared with the formal dining room, creating the perfect setting for entertaining or relaxing evenings at home. The expansive kitchen is truly the heart of the home, complete with quality cabinetry, a center island, peninsula breakfast bar, pantry, breakfast area, and attached sunroom perfectly positioned to capture the spectacular mountain views. Just off the oversized two-car garage, you’ll find a huge laundry/mudroom with an attached half bath for added convenience. The spacious primary suite features tray ceilings, two walk-in closets, and a luxurious attached bath with a soaking tub and walk-in shower. Two additional generously sized bedrooms and a large hall bath complete the main level. The fully finished walk-out lower level offers exceptional additional living space, including a massive rec room with pellet stove, fourth bedroom, third full bath, media/theater room, pool table area, workshop space, and abundant storage. Walk directly out to the lower-level patio from either the rec room or bedroom and enjoy the privacy of the beautifully maintained yard. Additional highlights include an enormous attic, heat pump with central air, outstanding curb appeal, and meticulous pride of ownership throughout. This is a rare opportunity to own a truly exceptional home in one of Cumberland’s most desirable locations.

10002 Carrington Ct, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Premier. Contact: (301) 777-3380

$514,990

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

A beautiful new construction home with a classic colonial facade awaits you! The Bristol II features the modern, open floor plan with dthe combined great room, breakfast room, and kitchen. A plethora of cabinets, a pantry plus the addition of a granite island, makes storage and counter space plenty within this kitchen. The gorgeous gas fireplace with a mantel makes the great room the perfect space for entertaining and spending time with family and friends. Multiple windows and a glass sliding door along the back of the home allows for plenty of natural light. The large, formal living room and dining rooms in the front of the home could be converted for use as an office, playroom, or library. The second floor features a large owner's bedroom with a private venetian ensuite with double vanity sinks that provides ample space. The owner's suite amenities include a large private walk-in and linen closet. There are 3 additional bedrooms, a bathroom and a laundry closet, centrally located for convenience and ease. This plan features several upgrades including 2' extensions on both sides and the rear of the home. The lower level has the option to add a recreational room, a den and a bathroom for an additional cost. Enjoy privacy and wildlife on this .42 acre lot on a quiet street. Several major employers nearby include UMPC Western Maryland Hospital, Northrop Grumman, Frostburg State University and Allegany College of Maryland to mention a few. Only minutes from Interstate 68 and Route 40. *Photos included in the listing are of a similar model home and not the actual home to be built.* Call for more information today!

Lot 10 Arrowhead Trl, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Premier. Contact: (301) 777-3380

$595,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to Sand Spring Run, Frostburg’s premier new development—where luxury living meets breathtaking mountain views. Perfectly positioned just minutes from Frostburg State University, downtown Frostburg, shopping, and dining, this community offers the ideal blend of convenience, comfort, and elevated style. This beautifully designed 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home showcases an inviting open floor plan created for modern living and effortless entertaining. Enjoy a spacious family room, elegant dining area, and a large eat-in kitchen that becomes the heart of the home. Thoughtfully designed walk-in closets, a full basement, and an attached garage provide the space and functionality today’s buyers expect. Even better—customization options are available, allowing you to personalize finishes and features to truly make this home your own. Step outside and take in the serene mountain views, adding a sense of peace and beauty to everyday living. Adding even more value and peace of mind, this exceptional home is being built by Battaglia West, a trusted and experienced contractor known for quality craftsmanship, attention to detail, and homes built to last. With a strong reputation for delivering well-constructed, thoughtfully designed residences, Battaglia West brings expertise, integrity, and pride to every project. From structural quality to refined finishes, you can feel confident knowing your home is being built by a builder who understands both luxury and livability. This is more than just a house—it’s a carefully crafted home in one of Frostburg’s most desirable communities. Sand Spring Run + Battaglia West = a winning combination. Now is the time to secure your place, customize your vision, and step into a home designed for comfort, beauty, and long-term value. Luxury homes are being built now—don’t miss your opportunity to secure a home in one of Frostburg’s most sought-after communities. Build your dream lifestyle at Sand Spring Run. Call today for more information!

126 Braddock Hts, Frostburg

Listing courtesy of EXP Realty, LLC. Contact: 8888607369

$599,888

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Brand New Home! Move-in Ready!! The Brandywine is a contemporary ranch-style home with 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a 2 car garage with drop zone entry, attached to a walk-in closet and laundry room, that leads through to the formal dining room. The Kitchen has a large amount of space, plenty of cabinets, and a large walk-in pantry, making storage and organization plentiful and manageable. The kitchen has upgraded full overlay cabinets, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a deluxe island. The well-equipped kitchen is ready for entertaining and cooking comforting meals for family and friends. The open breakfast area and large kitchen island offer a plethora of space for informal dining and entertaining. Or use this space as an extension of your cooking area for celebrating larger gatherings in the formal Dining Room. The kitchen flows effortlessly into the Great Room, which is spacious and is sure to be the center of activity and comfort in the home. A beautiful screened rear porch offers the perfect spot for outdoor entertaining. There are two entry points for the rear porch; one from the kitchen and one from the owner's suite. The owner's suite is an expansive bedroom with a private walk-in closet and bath. The Owner's Bath, has double vanities, a walk-in shower with a tiled bench seat, and a water closet. This home also features a choice room/library, perfect for use as a home office or playroom. This home is also complete and move-in ready!!

1107 Cherrywood Ave, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Premier. Contact: (301) 777-3380

Allegany County, MD Homes between $500,000 and $600,000 for Sale

Newest Allegany County, MD Homes between $500,000 and $600,000 for Sale